von Sojave » 1. Aug 2014 18:42
In my opinion it isnt cheating. Nobody have to stand for jury or get along with a book full of rules.
But
the animals should be treated as good as possible. Nothing wrong with pushing a small colony in the right amount early (if youre willing to take the "medical" risks, which should be normally small). Its only cheating if the antkeeper have to show how cool he is in some ways... Really? There are enough beginner who are starting with exotic and posting pictures and then it stopped. They selled it^^ Of course, the wouldnt say, that the colony died in nearly 95% of all cool antkeepers. So the cheating point is complete obsolete, as long as its the right amount, right species and the colony is old enough for the pushing. I think, our hobby isnt good to show off either. They should buy expensive and fast cars. Ah, one moment, that isnt good either for the boys.
So, we are responsible, that our animals (may it ants or dogs ect) are treated good. I have to admit, that we antkeeper have some problems at certain points and have to deal with some unwanted actions. First, the setup should be big enough and good for the species. We cant copy the nature, but most species dont need a copy, they develop well in our setups and that is what we wanted.
Remember that most keeper dont get to the point, where you have to add the 3rd arena. But if its our pet and it lasts so long, at some points we have to reduce the amount of ants. Personally i see the whole colony as 1 pet, not every ant. Maybe the Queen is an exeption on 1 queen colonies because her end is the end for the colony too. I wasnt in the position that i had to dispose some worker, so that i neednt to add a new arena.
The problems are often nothing directly the ants and their behaviour. Its the keeper. I dont mean it evil or so, but young kids see these pictures from exotic ants or big colonies from their homeland. The addional enthusiasm is doing the rest. Its easy to post a lot stuff and starting discussions. Every day they have to wait is one day to much and so they are posting instead. But most of it is already written a houndred times. Older ant keeper disapier with the time where you can see very good setups and big colonies. Sometimes i read a new thread or posts but i close it fast or dont answer in it.
Not cheating and i allow pushing as long as the parameters are good. I am complete against pushing as long as a claustral species like Lasius niger have no workers or not enough. (Some circumstances from above have to be cleared)
a bit offtopic: i think the system how you find an article from the shop is used often wrong by this people. Its the same on amazon ect. If the new beginner read it, it gives most of the time no good information. And if they get their package and they do a rating, the delevery time shouldnt be part of it. So we get statements that some species are uncool or hard to keep. Of course, a lot of species arent for beginner. Its not a matter of time or money...But its impossible now to change this in the world.All shops have to deal with this.